Comparative Analysis of Saga State Machine Designers: LogicFlow vs. diagram-js

[ptyin]

Introduction

Hello fellow developers! 👋 I hope you're all doing well. I'm reaching out to gather insights and opinions on the selection of a state machine designer for Seata Saga. The two options on the table are LogicFlow and diagram-js, and I would love to hear your thoughts on these tools.

LogicFlow

Pros:

1. Extensive Documentation: The documentation for LogicFlow is comprehensive, providing clear guidelines and examples to facilitate a smooth learning curve. Moreover, it offers Chinese version of docs.
2. Customization: LogicFlow allows a high degree of node and edge style customization, enabling developers to tailor to specific project requirements.

Cons:

1. Property Panel Complexity: The absence of a built-in property panel in LogicFlow requires developers to write our own, adding an extra layer of complexity to the customization process.

diagram-js

Pros:

1. Property Panel Support: Unlike LogicFlow, diagram-js comes with built-in support for property panels, reducing the need for developers to create this functionality from scratch.
2. Stability Assurance: Comprehensive unit testing in diagram-js ensures a higher level of stability, minimizing the chances of bugs and issues in your state machine implementation.

Cons:

1. Steep Learning Curve: Users might find diagram-js to have a steeper learning curve due to the missing of documentation. We have to look into the source code to see how it works. However, diagram-js provides examples and unit tests that we can get hands on.

Popularity

LogicFlow	diagram-js
5.9k ⭐️	1.5k ⭐️
195 versions	246 versions

Demo

LogicFlow	diagram-js

Your Input Matters!

Now, it's your turn! We're looking for your valuable insights and experiences with either LogicFlow or diagram-js. Have you used one of these tools in your projects? What were the strengths and weaknesses you observed?

Vote Now!

Please cast your vote. Feel free to share additional comments or considerations that influenced your choice. Let's collaborate to make an informed decision for our project! 🚀