Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

No longer maintained #163

Open
dave-theunsub opened this issue Mar 30, 2024 · 5 comments
Open

No longer maintained #163

dave-theunsub opened this issue Mar 30, 2024 · 5 comments

Comments

@dave-theunsub
Copy link
Owner

dave-theunsub commented Mar 30, 2024

As of today, after 20+ years, I'm considering myself retired.

There are many reasons why:

  • It's not that good anyway and has lousy reviews
  • I'm not a real programmer and will never be good at it
  • It needs to be redone, both in a different language and with a new design
  • Getting hit by a drunk driver in 2022 made my ability to focus even worse
  • clamtk was supposed to be a lightweight, easy to use program, and it's probably neither
  • It crashes upon closing all the time now and I have no idea why
  • ClamAV signatures take a long time to load upon startup; don't know how to tell that to the user waiting for the scan to begin. Yes, we can use clamd, I know.

There are more, and I could drone on about it but it doesn't add anything meaningful.

My goals were to give back to Linux, which gave me a lot, and to get better at programming. I probably did not do either. I did get more knowledgeable about how packaging works, but I suppose that's not relevant.

I do recommend these, though:

  • Quit calling Linux threats "viruses". Linux (and other OSes) are vulnerable to A LOT of threats, including malware and rootkits. Saying Linux doesn't get viruses is like saying your football team doesn't give up many homeruns. It's stupid. Linux systems need to be protected by defense-in-depth, and that doesn't include saying "it's secure because it's Linux". Malware is the right term, which encompasses many types of threats.
  • Someone should make a good malware scanner (GUI) for Linux (and related) systems.

Apologies for adding to the list of dead open source projects.

If I can start doing things again, I will. But probably not.

Thanks to all the wonderful people I've spoken to from all corners of the world, and take care.

@dave-theunsub dave-theunsub pinned this issue Mar 30, 2024
@digt100
Copy link

digt100 commented Mar 30, 2024

I always wanted to learn something about programming to actively contribute to open source projects. Unfortunately I never succeeded. Thanks Dave for your time on this great project. It would be really sad if clamtk was abandoned. I hope you can rethink it...anyway, thank you very much.

@GarryStraitYT
Copy link

I've used this on my Raspberry Pi. It's disappointing and yet motivating to see it go. Disappointing in the sense that a great program is dying, motivating in the sense that it makes me want to fork it and make it meet the requirements of the original developer. (New language and all that)

@caralu74
Copy link

THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR YOUR JOB TILL TO NOW!
I wish you could be happy and with little worries. Enjoy your family, your time. As well, I hope to read about you soon!
Thank you again.

@TickDracy
Copy link

As someone who transitioned (definitely) from Windows to Linux, I enjoy using GUIs whenever possible. It bothers me when people say: just use the terminal. Yes, I use it sometimes, but we can't rely solely on that. Otherwise, Linux will never get the casual user base it needs.

Well, personal thoughts aside, I want to express my gratitude for all the work you have put on ClamTK. I think you're being a bit harsh on yourself, and be more proud of what you accomplished. ClamTK is not bloated or anything like that. It has its own issues, but it's far from the negative perspective you are projecting.

I hope someone can continue your work (or restart it) because right now, I think there is a void for everyone who wants to use ClamAV without the terminal

Best of luck on your career.

@incrediblyimpressiveusername

This breaks my heart. Not because ClamTK is no longer maintained, but because Mr. Mauroni looks back so negatively on his 20+ years labor of love.

  • It's not that good anyway and has lousy reviews

ClamTK has its flaws certainly, but it is good nonetheless. Who cares about lousy reviews? If those reviewers could do better, they should have forked the project and proven it by doing better and becoming more successful.

  • clamtk was supposed to be a lightweight, easy to use program, and it's probably neither

It might not be perfect, but it absolutely is both lightweight and easy to use.

My goals were to give back to Linux, which gave me a lot, and to get better at programming. I probably did not do either. I did get more knowledgeable about how packaging works, but I suppose that's not relevant.

You did give back to Linux. And learning how packaging works is relevant, as well as inherently interesting.

  • Someone should make a good malware scanner (GUI) for Linux (and related) systems.

Kaspersky Endpoint Security for Linux is a good GUI malware scanner. Unfortunately, it isn't free as in beer nor as in speech.

Apologies for adding to the list of dead open source projects.

Don't feel bad for having created and maintained ClamTK.

Thanks to all the wonderful people I've spoken to from all corners of the world, and take care.

Thank you for your years of selfless work and dedication!

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

6 participants